Friday, June 14, 2013

Come on, PRL editors.

I rarely criticize papers.  I write this not to single out the authors (none of whom I know), nor to criticize the actual science (which seems very interesting) but to ask pointedly:  How did the editors of PRL, a journal that allegedly prizes readability by a general physics audience, allow this to go through in its current form?  This paper is titled "Poor Man’s Understanding of Kinks Originating from Strong Electronic Correlations".  A natural question would be, "Kinks in what?".  Unfortunately, the abstract doesn't say.  Worse, it refers to "the central peak".  Again, a peak in what?!   Something as a function of something, that's for sure. 

Come on, editors - if you are going to let articles be knocked from PRL contention because they're "more suitable for a specialized journal", that obligates you to make sure that the papers you do print at least have titles and abstracts that are accessible.  I'm even a specialist in the field and I wasn't sure what the authors were talking about (some spectral density function?) based on the title and abstract.

The authors actually do a good job explaining the issue in the very first sentence of the paper:  "Kinks in the energy vs. momentum dispersion relation indicate deviations from a quasiparticle renormalization of the noninteracting system."   That should have been the first sentence in the abstract.  In a noninteracting system, the relationship between energy and momentum of particles is smooth.  For example, for a free electron, \( E = p^{2}/2m \) where \(m\) is the mass.  In an ordinary metal (where Fermi liquid theory works), you can write a similar smooth relationship for the energy vs. momentum relationship of the quasiparticles. Kinks in that relationship, as the authors say, "provide valuable information of many-body effects".  


Doru Constantin said...

I'm afraid PRL is a victim of its own success. Probably due to the sheer number of submitted papers, the editors are reduced to simply tallying the points between referees and authors.

The referees are specialists, and the suitability for a general audience is not necessarily their first concern (although it can be a convenient way to dismiss the paper without addressing its content).

In my experience, the editorial process of the ACS is much more thorough.

Peter Armitage said...

I disagree with Doru that the problem is that the referees are specialists. What success? PRL is on a long slow death spiral due to the declining QUALITY of refereeing and of the editorializing (these are directly correlated). Its sad to see what was formally the premier journal in physics dieing a slow death from both the competition (from the Nature group and ACS) and from the thousand cuts of bad decisions made everyday from the management.

I've heard editors complain that it is hard to get good referees, but I know prominent people who never even get asked anymore. Why? I don't know. I used to think it was some sort of weird plan to increase diversity/generality in the articles by having them refereed by people well out of the relevant field. But now I think there is just no plan. All these weird things at PRL are just the result of the review process being a mostly random walk. Some papers go to one referee. Some papers go to 3. After reply to comments, some papers go back to the same referees, some go back to one new one... or three new ones... or to only the unfavorable ones and then some new ones. All of whom may not be working in the area. Further evidence there is no plan/procedure can be seen in that some papers are rejected for being too specialized, while others have comical titles and abstracts like the one Doug showed.

The journal needs clean-out/shake-up much like PRB got recently. I like PRB and my impression is that the whole editorial chain of command is commited to publishing the best science they can in our information age. I'm not sure what PRL is trying to do.

Charles Day said...

APS recently announced the appointment of a new lead editor for PRL, U of Arizona's Pierre Meystre.

Anonymous said...

Your article is good. I like style of your writing. So I got pleasure reading it. Thanks a lot!

kewin stewart said...

Great blog. I like your post thanks for sharing....

anisha kumari said...

Thanks for post this helpful post - Please visit for More information about -
Packers and Movers in Hyderabad
Packers and Movers in Pune
Packers and Movers in Mumbai
Packers and Movers in Chennai

anisha kumari said...

Thanks for post this helpful post - Please visit for More information about -
Packers and Movers in Delhi
Packers and Movers in Bangalore
Packers and Movers in Gurgaon
Packers and Movers in Pune

anisha kumari said...

Thanks for Nice and Informative Post. This article is really contains lot more information about This Topic. -
Packers and Movers in Noida
Packers and Movers in Thane
Packers and Movers in Navi Mumbai
Packers and Movers in Ghaziabad
Packers and Movers in Faridabad said...

Thanks for sharing your info. I really appreciate your efforts and I will be waiting for your further write
Packers and Movers Hyderabad
Packers and Movers Bangalore
Packers and Movers Mumbai
Packers and Movers Pune said...

If you are looking Best Packers and Movers so Visit at :
Packers and Movers Pune
Packers and Movers Delhi
Packers and Movers Gurgaon

Century Relocation Amit Nehra said...

You have shared very nice information regarding this social media. Really I got some new things from here. Packers And Movers In Pune

Swati Kumari said...

The article is very interesting and informative. Thanks for sharing.
movers and packers in delhi
packers and movers in navi mumbai
movers and packers in mumbai
movers and packers in pune
movers and packers in hyderabad
packers and movers in bangalore
chennai packers and movers

J J Logestics Packers And Movers said...

Thanks for useful information
packers and movers in kandivali
packers and movers in thane
packers and movers in mira road
packers and movers in panvel
packers and movers in kamothe
packers and movers in ghansoli
packers and movers in koparkhairane
packers and movers in malad
packers and movers in powai
packers and movers in nerul
packers and movers in airoli
packers and movers in andheri west
packers and movers in andheri east
packers and movers in bandra west
packers and movers in bandra east

Jam Lisvi said...

SEO Virginia Just stumbled across your blog and was instantly amazed with all the useful information that is on it. Great post, just what i was looking for and i am looking forward to reading your other posts soon!

Operations Management said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Ari sh said...

Thanks for posting this article - movers and packers hsr layout movers and packers marathahalli movers and packers btm layout movers and packers bommanahalli movers and packers koramangala movers and packers jp nagar