Dear Dr. Natelson,Well, I guess we'll see what happens. It'll be interesting to see if anything comes of this. I'm quite sure there's something fishy about the particular paper, but it may be very hard to ever prove.
We are in the process of considering the issues you raise about the
Letter by XXXXX et al. Such consideration often takes a substantial
amount of time. Fortunately, in the present case, in which the paper
at issue was published six years ago, there does not appear to be
cause for time pressure. We will apprise you of our conclusion when
we reach it.
Reinhardt B. Schuhmann
Physical Review Letters
Monday, May 22, 2006
I just received the following email from Phys Rev Letters:
Posted by Douglas Natelson at 9:08 AM